I bought this for my living room door

I fitted this item to my living room door. It was easy to fit but is taking some adjusting so that the door closed every time.

Really noisy!!

I fitted one of these to the living room door as it was easier then training the dog to close the door behind her. For about 2 hours it was great but then it started to creak. By the following day it was so noisy it sounded like a door in an old castle and was waking up the kids in the evening. Needless to say I’ve removed it and sent it back. I didn’t bother with WD40 as the main issue seemed to be internally with the spring itself. The fixings are rubbish as well, the heads strip out or just break off. I can’t remove the cheap plastic slide guide without breaking it and getting some mole grips on the screw head. Really disappointing as it looked ok and seemed like a good solution. I’m getting really fed up with buying stuff on the internet in good faith and it turning out to be rubbish. The only bright side is that it was for my own home and not a client. If I’d had to go back to a job and remove one that would be time and money and that isn’t acceptable.

Does the job well

Bought this for a bathroom door that was hung slightly off the vertical and naturally swung into a 2/3 open position. Easy to instal; closing force adjustable. It does exactly what we wanted - the door now naturally moves back toward the closed position when we go through it.

Ok for the job, but plastic "door slider" could have been better

Bought this to keep an old door closed. Works well enough, but the part that is put on the door (push plate) is white plastic, with one retaining screw. This needs to be longer (with ideally 2 retaining screws), and would have been much better if it were brass effect as outlined in the picture.

Not fit for purpose

When carpenter fitted one of the locks it only closed half way despite the door being only 16kg and no floor obstruction.